Many of us are guitarists, and most of us probably love to geek out on gear and tone as much as we like to actually play. After all, finding our individual “holy grail” tone is half of what makes playing guitar so much fun! But what happens when it’s time to record and mix? What we hear in the room versus what we hear tracked can be two different things. Luckily, there are a handful of go-to tricks for mixing guitars to get the most out of the instrument, while striking a balance with everything else.
1. High. Pass. Filter!
Have we stressed the importance of high pass filtering enough yet? Unfortunately, there’s so much misinformation out there about filtering, particularly high pass filtering. Some engineers have even gone so far as to say not using HPFs is preferable. In reality, this just isn’t the case.
Filtering does so much of the heavy lifting when it comes to balancing mix elements and letting each instrument live in its own frequency range. Of course, when it comes to mixing guitars, filtering is no exception. You don’t want the guitar to clash with bass, so filtering out its lowest frequencies is essential.
Depending on tuning and other factors, start high passing somewhere around 80 Hz. In many cases you’ll find that you can even go up much higher.
2. Subtle Modulation for Depth/Character
I don’t know about you, but I often take for granted the idea that effects (pedals) can be used tastefully in spare amounts. As a guitarist myself, I tend to think of tone as an all or nothing venture: this is my clean tone with reverb and delay, this is my chorus tone, or my flanger tone, etc.
When mixing guitars, though, you can add just a bit of modulation for added character and depth. It doesn’t have to be a completely “effected” sound at all. Try using a hint of chorus or flanger on a guitar mix some time; you might find something really interesting!
3. Stereo Delay
If your guitar mix feels a bit thin, try tossing on a stereo delay for some extra width. Something short, just beyond the Haas effect, maybe between 60 and 100 ms, will widen your guitar’s sound without being noticeably delayed. The idea is to create a false doubling effect without taking up too much space in the mix or sounding totally wrong.
4. Double Track Rhythm Parts
One of the first guitar tracking/mixing techniques I learned was to double track the rhythm parts. Especially great for hard rock/metal, tracking two unique performances of a section and panning them left and right creates a massive sound.
Experiment with hard panning each take, or bring them in slightly for less width while retaining depth and dimension. If you’re a metal player and haven’t tried this yet, you’ll be blown away by how crushing it can sound!
If you try to simply duplicate a single take and pan those opposite each other, you’re only panning a mono source. Two different performances and the subtle differences between them are what creates the stereo width and depth we’re after.
To compensate for if/when your track is summed to mono, use different guitar tones on each of the separate channels!
5. Pan a Mono Reverb
If you’re trying to gel a guitar in a dense mix, try using mono reverb returns instead of stereo ones. This gives you more control over where the guitar sits in the mix. The reverb gives it the space it needs, and keeping it mono means you can push it to one side or the other. Stereo reverbs are less controlled because they fill the stereo field entirely.
6. Keep Distortion Tasteful
Looking at you, metal players! Sometimes we’re swayed by the false notion that more distortion = heavier tone. In reality, more distortion = more noise, less articulation, and an unintelligible pile of fizz.
Whether you’re mixing with amp sims on a DI or tracking an amplifier, keep the distortion in check. Some of the current heaviest progressive metal bands actually use very little distortion; instead, they push their amp or sim harder with an overdrive. The crunch and grit is still there, but with more clarity than a fizzy, noisy distortion can offer.
7. Focus on the Midrange
Guitars are midrange instruments. Don’t sweat the low end too much; that’s where the bass guitar shines. And don’t sweat the high end (8+ kHz) either; there isn’t much information up there. Instead, focus on getting the guitar’s dominant frequencies to sound their absolute best.
Every guitar is a little different, but sweeping around with an EQ can help you find your instrument’s sweet spot.
8. Low Pass Filter!
High pass filtering is essential—hopefully that’s been instilled! But so is low pass filtering. We’ve just discussed how guitars are predominantly a midrange instrument, with little useful information in the low, low end, or the high, high end. Filtering out some of the unnecessary highs will leave room for every other important mix element. Mixing is all about balance, and mixing guitars is no exception.
9. Bus Tracks Together
It should go without saying that bussing is your best friend. If you have 4 or more tracks of rhythm guitar, you could take the time to process them all individually, or you could route them to a bus with a guitar mixing chain already on it. This not only saves time and processing power, but also ensures cohesion amongst the various tracks you’ve routed there.
10. Skip the Solo Button
Mix in context. It’s as simple as that! Understandably, if you’re sweeping for surgical EQ, soloing is perfectly acceptable. Just be sure you’re not spending all of your time mixing guitars by themselves. It’s a common mistake to make something sound amazing on its own, but when the rest of the mix comes in, all the work we did doesn’t sit right.
Keeping the big picture in mind will make sure you’re mixing for the sake of the overall track, and not just for the sake of great sounding guitars.